Fancy- I've always secretly admired that saddle!! That's the shape my BR has, maybe a little more narrow... I don't think that's something that could work on him. It looks very wide at the bottom, but up top, it's really not that wide. He needs it wide up top by his shoulders if that makes sense. Timmysmom- My Circle Y fits him better than anything, so that makes sense. Unfortunately, I cannot stand to ride in those saddles. So, I've ruled out Circle Y's.